Are colored vinyl records more valuable than black vinyls?


By Storyhub

When vinyl rose from its ashes over a decade ago, debates around it erupted here and there. Much like the ongoing debate over the best music format (CD or vinyl), a debate over which type of vinyl record is best is now being discussed, especially by musicians who are considering making their debut. custom vinyl pressing.

There have been many slanders about colorful vinyl records which are quite outdated, so we have come to defend them. We will not defend them blindly, as we will discuss this issue after doing more research on the issue.

Before that, let’s first see the difference between color vinyl records and black vinyl records because they both have their pros and cons and in the end it’s up to you which one is better.


Pressing vinyl records because black vinyl records are still plentiful to this day and it has something to do with its affordability. Additionally, black vinyl records are said to sound better than colored records (but we’ll cover that in more detail later).

A few years during the war between cylinder and record phonographs, colored vinyl records were introduced in 1908. During this time, Thomas Edison also released his Blue Amberol cylinders to gain favor for his format. However, it gave fans of the records the idea to add color to theirs.

All kinds of vinyl records are made from polyvinyl chloride, or more commonly known as PVC, hence the format gets its name. PVC is initially a colorless synthetic plastic polymer, which requires dyes to acquire its color.


To give color to black vinyl records, carbon black is added to the PVC mixture while the dyes are those added to color vinyl records. Although the added carbon black strengthens the mixture, dyes cannot strengthen the mixture in the same way as carbon black.

In addition, carbon black can also reduce static electricity. This static electricity apparently attracts dust and dirt to the surface of the vinyl record, which can cause pops and clicks during playback.


Another factor that makes color vinyl records different from blacks is their malleability. Malleability is a necessary characteristic when pressing tracks onto the disc surface.

For black vinyl records, this malleability is the same, which makes their quality stable and excellent since black is a malleable color. Colorful vinyl records, on the other hand, have different malleability, depending on the dye used to obtain its color, and the pressing plant that you had your custom vinyl pressing do it. Learn more about vinyl pressing manufacturing to better understand it.


Black vinyl records use carbon as a colorant, and carbon reduces static electricity. However, the main factor that people say black vinyl records sound better isn’t really because of this, it’s because black is the standard color for vinyl records. It is the most in a hurry, the most used, and therefore the most consistent. Vinyl factories, even the newer ones, are experts in making black vinyl records.

When you make a colored vinyl record, the materials are different and that makes the whole process a bit more “experimental”. And of course, it could affect the sound.

However, today many of these factories squeeze colored vinyl records, so there is almost no risk.


Because it’s prettier, of course!

If you press black vinyl record and colored vinyl records, there is a good chance that people will be drawn to the colored records.

You might think, but it’s not that important! And you’d be surprised if that was the case, especially now that we’re all going digital. We want our records to look pretty or we just prefer to listen to iTunes.



It is said that colored vinyl records with a single color are better than the way they are portrayed in some debates about black and color vinyl records. It all depends on the dyes used because they can affect the malleability of the PVC mixture.

According to Matt Earley of Gotta Grooves Records, white records are the loudest, in their experience of pressing vinyl records. And when that white mixture is mixed with another dye to make another color, it gets worse.


Clear vinyl records are said to be on par with black vinyl records when it comes to consistent play. They say that black and transparent are the most malleable. This consistency also applies to transparencies color vinyl records. They are also considered better than monochrome opaque ones.


Multi-color vinyl records may be the worst among the types of color vinyl records. This is due to the fact that it composes different PVC blends with different malleability and melting capacity.

Imagine having different colors of different PVC blends complementing a vinyl record. When the tracks are pressed or cut in this recording, there will be differences in the way they are formed or molded. This can result in inconsistent sound making it awful.


Dye used

Some would say that colors affect the sound quality of vinyl records, but it is not really the color but the ingredient used to achieve that color. Colorful vinyl records need dyes to color and these dyes have different compositions. This causes a difference between the different color registrations because some dyes can bring benefit or cause harm. It will really depend on what dye your baling plant will be using for the custom vinyl pressing.

Your pressing plant

Different pressing factories have different suppliers of PVC granules with different PVC recipes. Different recipes mean different qualities. In addition, there are pressing factories with different ways of producing their records.

So if you are planning to have your own vinyl record, it would be best to look for a pressing factory that presses their vinyl records well. To make sure you’re in good hands, try listening to vinyl records they’ve pressed for other musicians. This way you can evaluate their work for yourself and not by the suggestion or experience of others.

Pressed tracks

The track that you submit to your pressing plant will greatly affect the quality of sound that your vinyl record will provide in the end. If your tracks weren’t mastered for vinyl, I’m pretty sure it would sound awful.


So that’s about it, guys. If you are quality conscious and want to play it safe, go for black vinyl records. It is a sure way to have good sound quality. Your recordings can seem a bit boring, however.

But if you want to have very beautiful records, go for colored records! Just make sure you pick a good vinyl mastering service and a good pressing plant and you’re good to go.

If we really have to answer, what is most valuable? The answer really depends on a lot of factors. But one thing I’m sure, if I want to buy a vinyl album, surely I need more than great music – I need it to be something beautiful … something worth doing. be added to my collection. Black or colored, you decide, and of course, the buyer.


Leave A Reply